Interest Rates on Federal Education Loans are Dropping on July 1, 2009
The interest rates on older variable-rate federal education loans will be dropping to new historic lows on July 1, 2009. This will save borrowers who wait until July 1, 2009 to consolidate variable rate loans thousands of dollars of interest over the life of their loans.
Variable vs. Fixed Rate Loans
Federal Stafford and PLUS loans fall into two groups:
- Loans originated before July 1, 2006 have variable interest rates that reset each July 1 based on the last 91-day T-Bill rate auction in May. They continue resetting each July 1 until the borrower chooses to lock in the rate by consolidating the loans. The interest rates on these loans will be dropping to new historic lows on July 1, 2009.
- Loans originated on or after July 1, 2006 have fixed interest rates. The unsubsidized Stafford Loan has a 6.8% interest rate. The PLUS loan has an interest rate of 7.9% (Direct Loan program schools) or 8.5% (FFEL program schools). The interest rate on the subsidized Stafford loan for undergraduate students is also fixed, but each year new loans are at a different rate because of a phased-in interest rate reduction passed by the College Cost Reduction and Access Act of 2007. The interest rate in 2008-09 was 6.0% and the interest rate in 2009-10 (for new loans starting July 1, 2009) will be 5.6%, followed by 4.5%, then 3.4%, and then reverting to 6.8% if the change isn’t extended by Congress. Subsidized Stafford loans for graduate students remain at 6.8%.
Locking in the New Variable Interest Rates
The last 91-day T-bill rate auction in May occurred on May 26, 2009 with an investment rate of 0.178%, yielding the following new variable rates that go into effect on July 1, 2009:
- Stafford Loan (In-School/Grace Period): 1.88%
- Stafford Loan (Repayment Period): 2.48%
- PLUS Loan: 3.28%
These rates are 1.727% lower than the interest rates in effect in 2008-09, and are the lowest interest rates in the history of the federal student loan program. The previous low was in 2004-05 when in-school/grace period rates on the Stafford loan hit 2.77%.
Borrowers can lock in the current applicable rate on variable-rate loans by consolidating them. The interest rate on a consolidation loan is a fixed rate that is the weighted average of the current applicable interest rates on the loans being consolidated, rounded up to the nearest 1/8th of a point and capped at 8.25%.
Thus borrowers with variable rate loans who consolidate them after July 1, 2009 will obtain the following consolidation loan interest rates:
- Stafford Loan Consolidation (In-School/Grace Period): 2.00%
- Stafford Loan Consolidation (Repayment Period): 2.50%
- PLUS Loan Consolidation: 3.38%
Bottom Line Advice
Borrowers who still have variable rate loans should wait until July 1, 2009 to consolidate their loans.
Potential Savings
Borrowers who wait until July 1, 2009 to consolidate variable rate loans will save thousands of dollars in interest over the life of their loans.
For example, compare the cost of a $20,000 Stafford loan with a 6.8% interest rate (the current fixed rate and also the historical average interest rate) with the cost of a variable rate Stafford loan with the interest rate locked in at 2.0%. The monthly payment on the 2.0% rate loan over a standard 10-year repayment term is $184 and the total interest paid over the life of the loan is $2,083, compared with $230 and $7,619 on a 6.8% rate loan. This represents a 20% lower monthly payment and total interest savings of $5,536 (73%). Over an extended 20-year repayment term the monthly payment on the 2.0% rate loan is $101 and the total interest paid is $4,282 compared with $153 and $16,640 on the 6.8% rate loan. That represents a one-third (33%) lower monthly payment and total interest savings of $12,358 (74%).
Compared with consolidating at the current grace period rate of 3.635%, the savings are still substantial. A borrower with $20,000 in variable-rate debt who waits until July 1, 2009 to consolidate will save $1,790 (46%) in interest over the life of a 10-year loan and $3,865 (47%) in interest over the life of a 20-year loan and will benefit from a $15 to $16 reduction in the monthly payment.
How to Consolidate Your Loans
Since most federally-guaranteed student loan program lenders are no longer consolidating federal education loans, borrowers who wish to consolidate their loans should use the Federal Direct Loan Consolidation program at loanconsolidation.ed.gov.
Exceptions and Caveats
Borrowers who have already consolidated their loans cannot take advantage of the drop in interest rates, as it is not possible to relock the rates after the loans have been consolidated. Borrowers with loans originated after July 1, 2006 are not eligible for the new lower rates, as these rates are only available to borrowers with varaible rate loans. Private student loans cannot be included in a federal consolidation loan. Borrowers who are still in school cannot consolidate their loans until they graduate, as Congress repealed the early repayment status loophole in 2006.
Borrowers who received prompt payment discounts from their lender will lose those discounts if they consolidate. Borrowers who received up-front discounts on their loans, such as fee waivers, may lose those discounts if they consolidate, depending on the terms of the discounts. However, generally the savings associated with locking in the loans at historically low interest rates will outweigh the value of the lost discounts.
It is not advisable to include Perkins loans in a consolidation loan, as one loses the subsidized interest and favorable forgiveness benefits associated with a Perkins loan if the loan is consolidated. Also, since the interest rate on the Perkins loan is already fixed, there is no financial benefit to consolidating them.
Likewise, there is no financial benefit to including fixed-rate federal education loans in with variable rate loans in a consolidation loan (other than possibly masking a portion of the 1/8th of a point round-up, depending on the loan balances). However, to the extent that the weighted average preserves the underlying cost of the loans, there is also little harm in including fixed rate Stafford and PLUS loans in with variable rate loans in a consolidation loan. Borrowers may wish to consolidate the loans together to simplify the repayment process.
There is no requirement that a borrower who consolidates his or her loans switch from standard ten-year repayment to a longer repayment plan, such as extended repayment or the new income-based repayment plan. Some borrowers may choose to use extended repayment to maximize the term of the historically low interest rate. However, if they do so, they should use the reduction in the monthly payment to pay down more expensive debt. Otherwise they are merely increasing the amount of interest they will pay over the life of the loan.